Review · THE USA
Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake
Deer Run Winery keeps this tasting small, simple, and refreshingly personal. In about 45 minutes, you sit with four three-ounce pours, each matched with a bite of cheese or chocolate. The $20 price is a strong draw, since you receive a generous total pour without committing to a full bottle.
I like the easy mix of styles, from dry-leaning Conesus White to sweet Max Black, and I like the relaxed staff-led setting. Candi, Sam, Hailey, and Grace have each been singled out for warm service, while the tiny tasting room can feel more like a visit to a country kitchen than a polished wine showroom. The tradeoff is that the chocolate portions are modest, and you should not expect a sweeping lake view or a full meal in the tasting price.
Key points to know before you go

- Four three-ounce pours: You receive 12 ounces of wine in total, split across four selections.
- Two cheese pairings and two chocolate pairings: The food samples are small, useful complements rather than a meal.
- A six-person maximum: This is a much more intimate setup than a large winery flight.
- Several sweetness levels: The flight moves from a semi-dry white to a red blend, sweet blush, and sweet red.
- A $20 tasting near Conesus Lake: The cost compares well with the amount of wine poured.
- A short, seated stop: Plan on roughly 45 minutes, with the option to remain nearby for food if available.
A small Finger Lakes tasting with a country-kitchen feel
Deer Run Winery sits at 3772 West Lake Road in Geneseo, close to Conesus Lake. This is part of the wider Finger Lakes wine area, but the experience does not try to imitate a grand estate winery.
That difference matters. You will not walk into a vast tasting hall with rows of visitors and a long formal presentation. The room is small, and the staff handles the tasting in a personal way. On a quiet day, you may find yourself sipping at a table with very little fuss around you.
That can be a plus if you want conversation, a calm setting, and enough space to pay attention to each pour. It can feel less exciting if you want a busy social stop with views, displays, or a full wine-country production.
The group limit is six people. That cap keeps the tasting from becoming unwieldy, although the exact feel will depend on who else has booked. Some sittings may involve sharing a table with another couple or small group.
The setting is close to the lake, but it does not provide a lake view. Keep that in mind when planning your day. Come for the wine, pairings, and friendly service, then treat the surrounding Conesus Lake area as a separate part of your outing.
More Cheese and Chocolate Tastings in the USA:
- Wine, Bread, Cheese and Chocolate
★ 5.0 · 81 reviews - New Orleans VIP Sightseeing Flight with Champagne & Chocolates or Wine & Cheese
★ 5.0 · 50 reviews - Seattle: Wine, Cheese and Chocolate Pairing Tour
★ 4.4 · 17 reviews
Four wines that cover a wide range of tastes

The tasting has a clear rhythm. You receive four wines, each poured at three ounces, with two paired to cheese and two paired to chocolate.
Here is what you can expect:
- Conesus White: A semi-dry white with grape-forward notes. It has won a gold medal and is served with cheese.
- Runway Red: A smooth red blend with berry and black pepper notes. It has earned best-in-category and gold-medal honors, and it is also paired with cheese.
- Pebble Beach Blush: A sweet blend with peach and melon notes. It has received a double gold award and comes with chocolate.
- Max Black: The best-selling sweet red blend, with grape-jelly notes. It is paired with chocolate and has also earned a gold medal.
I like the range here because the flight does not assume that everyone drinks wine the same way. The white and red pairings give you a chance to compare more traditional table-wine styles, while the blush and sweet red offer a softer, fruitier finish.
If you prefer dry wine, the first half will likely be more comfortable. If you enjoy sweet wines, the last two pours are the main attraction. One person can easily prefer three of the four and still find the tasting worthwhile.
The sequence also makes sense with the food. Cheese works naturally with the white and red, while chocolate fits the sweeter wines. The pairings are not elaborate plates. Expect small portions such as cheese curds and chocolate samples, enough to show the idea without replacing lunch.
How the seated tasting works

Your tasting begins at Deer Run Winery and ends at the same location. You do not move between several vineyards or spend time boarding transport. That keeps the experience compact and makes it easy to add before or after another Conesus Lake plan.
A sheet explains the wines and pairings, giving you a useful reference as you taste. Staff may talk through the grapes and the character of each bottle, and the level of conversation can vary with the size and pace of the group.
That informal style is part of the appeal. You can ask questions without feeling as if you have interrupted a formal lecture. Staff members such as Sam, Hailey, Grace, and Candi have been praised for making the tasting friendly and enjoyable, with Candi also helping people settle in with water and time to recover before driving.
The flight lasts about 45 minutes. That is long enough to compare the wines but short enough to fit into a broader Finger Lakes day. If you plan to buy bottles, allow extra time after the official tasting. Deer Run’s Max Black, in particular, is a popular choice for people who prefer sweet red wine.
What the cheese and chocolate add

The pairings are there to help you notice how food changes the wine, not to provide a substantial snack.
The cheese accompanies Conesus White and Runway Red. With the white, pay attention to how the cheese can soften the wine’s fruit-forward character. With the red, the cheese gives you a way to compare the berry and black pepper notes against something savory.
The chocolate pairings come with Pebble Beach Blush and Max Black. A small piece of chocolate can make a sweet wine feel rounder and more dessert-like. This is especially relevant with Max Black, whose grape-jelly character already points in that direction.
Portions are limited. A typical setup may include cheese curds, a small piece of Lindt chocolate, and a mini peanut butter cup. If you are booking mainly for food, you may feel the value is thinner. One visitor felt the chocolate pairings were expensive for their size, even while enjoying the wines and friendly host.
I would treat the food as a tasting tool, not as a cheese board or dessert course. If you want lunch, plan that separately.
More Wine and Cheese Tastings in the USA:
- Los Angeles: Luxury Cruise with Wine, Cheese & Sea Lions
★ 4.9 · 116 reviews - Temecula Valley 4-Hour Morning Wine Tour with Tastings Included
★ 5.0 · 103 reviews - Temecula Valley Afternoon Wine Tour with Tastings and Cheeseboard
★ 5.0 · 65 reviews - New York City: Champagne, Cheese, Caviar & Sightseeing Cruise
★ 4.5 · 26 reviews
Why the $20 price works for some people

At $20 per person, this tasting offers four three-ounce pours. That is about 12 ounces of wine, or close to four-fifths of a standard 750-milliliter bottle in total. For a short winery stop, that is a generous amount.
The value looks even better if you enjoy most of the styles offered. You can sample a white, a red blend, a blush, and a sweet red before deciding what to buy. This is more useful than committing to a bottle based only on a label or a staff recommendation.
The value is less clear if you dislike sweet wine. Two of the four pours are sweet blends, so some of your tasting is devoted to styles you may not want. The food is also sample-sized, and lunch is not included.
Still, the price compares favorably with the amount of wine served. A past visitor described receiving about twice the wine for roughly half the usual tasting cost they had encountered elsewhere. I would not treat that as a universal comparison, but it captures the main point: the flight is designed to give you plenty to try for a modest fee.
You can also sometimes add individual wine samples for $1 each, based on the experience of a prior visit. That option can be useful if you want to explore beyond the four featured pours, though it is not part of the stated tasting package and availability may vary.
Friendly service is the main attraction

The wine selection matters, but the people shape the visit.
Candi has been praised for her attentive welcome, water refills, and engaging approach. Sam has been described as enthusiastic while explaining the wines. Hailey helped make a solo visit feel social and interesting, while Grace talked through the grapes in a way that helped one couple compare several bottles.
Those details tell you what kind of place Deer Run is. You are likely to get a direct, human welcome rather than a scripted presentation. The owners may also stop by to talk, depending on the day.
The small staff is a strength, but it can also affect the pace. A tiny operation may feel quiet when few people are present, and service can feel less eventful than at a large winery with several rooms and scheduled activities. If you want a polished production, Deer Run may seem basic. If you want a relaxed conversation and a chance to linger over a glass, that simplicity works in its favor.
Water is available, and taking a little time before driving is sensible. The tasting is not a race. You have enough wine in the flight that you should plan your next stop responsibly.
Adding lunch at the Tankroom Café
Lunch is not part of the $20 tasting. However, people have combined the flight with a meal at the Tankroom Café on the property or nearby within the winery setting.
Food mentioned includes a burger and chips, along with other meals described as fresh and satisfying. Since the tasting itself is light, adding lunch can turn this into a more complete stop. You should confirm current food service and hours when planning, since the supplied details do not specify a dining schedule or menu.
This combination works well for a date or an unhurried afternoon. The wine flight gives you a short structured activity, and lunch gives you time to continue the visit without rushing back onto the road.
Do not book the tasting expecting lunch to appear automatically. If you need a full meal, ask about the café when you arrive or make a separate plan.
Who will enjoy this tasting most

I would recommend Deer Run Winery to several types of visitors.
Couples get a low-key date stop with enough variety to make the tasting interesting. The small room and shared-table possibility can feel sociable without forcing you into a large group.
Sweet-wine drinkers have a real reason to book. Pebble Beach Blush and Max Black make up half the flight, and both focus on fruit-forward sweetness.
Wine beginners should find the format approachable. Four wines, a short explanation sheet, and simple food pairings are easier to follow than a long technical tasting.
Solo visitors can also feel comfortable here. The staff has a personal style, and the short format does not leave you stranded in a large room.
People seeking dramatic scenery should adjust their expectations. You are near Conesus Lake, but there is no stated lake view. The winery itself is smaller and more modest than some Finger Lakes properties.
Likewise, serious wine collectors may want more depth than four house selections. You can sometimes add extra pours, but the main experience is a friendly introduction to Deer Run’s popular bottles rather than a technical exploration of vintage, vineyard, or production methods.
Practical details before booking
The activity costs $20 per person and lasts about 45 minutes. It is usually booked around two weeks ahead, so reserving in advance is sensible if your Finger Lakes schedule is fixed.
You receive mobile ticketing and booking confirmation at the time of purchase. The maximum group size is six, which helps keep the tasting personal.
Most people can take part, and service animals are allowed. The activity begins and ends at Deer Run Winery, 3772 W Lake Road, Geneseo, New York 14454.
Cancellation is flexible if you act early. You can receive a full refund by canceling at least 24 hours before the local start time. Cancellations or changes made within 24 hours are not refunded or accepted.
Plan your transport with the wine volume in mind. Four three-ounce pours are not a token sample. If you are driving, arrange a sober driver or use another safe plan.
Should you book the Deer Run wine tasting?
Book this experience if you want a short, friendly winery stop with a good amount of wine, clear food matches, and a wide spread of sweetness levels. The $20 cost is especially attractive if you enjoy red blends, blush wines, or dessert-style bottles.
I would be more cautious if you want a large tasting room, a scenic lake panorama, a full cheese board, or a meal built into the ticket. The room is small, the food bites are modest, and half the flight leans sweet.
For most people visiting the Conesus Lake area, this is an easy addition to the day. Go with realistic expectations, ask about the wines, consider lunch afterward, and leave room in your plans for a bottle of the style you liked best.
FAQ
Where does the wine, chocolate, and cheese tasting take place?
It takes place at Deer Run Winery, 3772 W Lake Road, Geneseo, New York 14454, USA, near Conesus Lake.
How long does the tasting last?
The tasting lasts approximately 45 minutes.
How much does the tasting cost?
The listed price is $20 per person.
How many wines are included?
You receive four wines, with a three-ounce pour of each wine.
Which wines are served?
The flight includes Conesus White, Runway Red, Pebble Beach Blush, and Max Black.
What food comes with the wines?
Two wines are paired with cheese and two are paired with chocolate. The tasting does not include lunch.
How many people can join the activity?
The maximum group size is six people.
Can I cancel for a full refund?
Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the experience start time for a full refund. Cancellations made within 24 hours are not refunded.
Freshly cut around the USA
- Romantic Luxury Boat Cruise with Wine Cheese Sea LionTours★ 5.0 · 11 reviews
- Sonoma Coast Tasting Tour: Cheese, Honey, Oysters, Wine and Oils★ 4.0 · 2 reviews
- Romantic Wine and Cheese Boat Tower Cruise★ 5.0 · 4 reviews
- New York City: Champagne, Cheese, Caviar & Sightseeing Cruise★ 4.5 · 26 reviews
- Epoxy Resin Cheese Board Art Class★ 5.0 · 15 reviews
- Sunset Wine & Cheese Emerald Bay Boat Charter★ 5.0 · 24 reviews
- Wine Tasting with Cheese, Charcuterie, and Dessert Experience★ 4.0 · 17 reviews
- Fortune Reading with Cheese in Chicago★ 5.0 · 19 reviews
Cheese and Chocolate Tastings, plate by plate.

Porto: Cálem Cellar with Chocolate, Cheese, and Wine Tasting
Read our review →
Zurich Food Tour with 10 Local Delicacies, Cheeses & Chocolates
Read our review →
Lucerne CH Experience: Cheese, Chocolate, Chapel Bridge & Château
Read our review →Cheese lists with this tasting





