Review · ITALY

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting

★ 4.0 · 12 reviews 45 minutes (approx.) From $66 Operated by Podere la Marronaia · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

The best part of this experience is the setting: a working organic farm outside San Gimignano, where your table may look across olive trees and vineyards toward the town’s famous towers. You’ll taste four Tuscan wines, six olive oils, local cheeses, bruschette, and truffle-based dishes rather than simply stopping for a quick glass of Vernaccia.

I like the family-run scale and the short walk from the historic center. I also like the range of products, especially the flavored oils made with basil, garlic, chili pepper, white truffle, and rosemary. The main drawback is that this is primarily a seated tasting, not a guided visit through the vineyards or wine cellar, and the location can be awkward to find by car.

Key points to know

  • About 800 meters from San Gimignano’s center: Close enough to walk, but not inside the medieval streets.
  • Four wines included: Vernaccia, Chianti or rosato, Sangiovese, and Vinsanto with cantucci.
  • Six olive oils to taste: One natural extra virgin oil and five flavored versions.
  • Organic production: Podere la Marronaia has used organic methods since 2000 and received organic certification in 2003.
  • Views are part of the appeal: Outdoor seating can look toward San Gimignano’s towers and the Vernaccia vineyard.
  • Private booking: Only your own group participates, with no hotel pickup or private transportation included.

A farm setting just beyond San Gimignano’s towers

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting - A farm setting just beyond San Gimignano’s towers

San Gimignano is famous for its medieval towers, narrow lanes, and crowds gathered around the central streets. This tasting gives you a different view of the town. At Sosta Alle Colonne, the farm’s tasting venue, you sit in the countryside with the towers in the distance and vineyards nearby.

The venue is described as about 800 meters from the city center, so you can reach it on foot. That distance matters. You are not stepping into a shop on the main square for a five-minute sample. You are leaving the stone lanes and heading toward the land that produces the food and wine associated with Tuscany.

The walk should be simple for most people, but the experience is not located within the medieval center itself. If you are driving, take the directions seriously. Parking is in or near an olive grove, and the approach can include a steep section that is not especially easy to maneuver. I would choose walking from town if that works for you.

The farm belongs to Podere la Marronaia, a small family operation devoted to grapes, olives, wine, and extra virgin olive oil. Since 2000, the farm has used organic methods based on natural products and the natural fertility of the soil. Its products have been certified organic since 2003.

That does not turn the tasting into a lesson on farming, but it gives the bottles a useful sense of place. You are tasting products made from the same Tuscan soil and climate visible around you.

What you taste in the four-wine flight

The wine portion gives you four different styles, and it follows a sensible Tuscan path.

First comes Vernaccia di San Gimignano DOCG, the local white wine. Vernaccia is not usually a soft, fruity white in the style of Chardonnay. It tends to be mineral and crisp, with a sharper edge. If you prefer round, sweet-tasting whites, you may find it sour or austere. If you want to taste the wine most closely linked to San Gimignano, this is the essential glass.

The second wine is either an organic Chianti Colli Senesi DOCG or an organic rosato from Tuscany. The exact option may depend on the tasting arrangement. Chianti gives you a red wine connected with the wider Tuscan tradition, while rosato offers a lighter choice that may work better on a warm afternoon.

The third is Sangiovese IGT Rosso Toscano, made from Tuscany’s best-known red grape. This is a useful contrast with Vernaccia. Instead of the white’s mineral character, you get the broader red-wine profile associated with Sangiovese.

The final pairing is Vinsanto with cantucci. This is the sweet finish that many visitors expect from a Tuscan meal. The dry almond biscuit is traditionally dipped into the wine, so do not treat the two as separate samples. The pairing is the point.

You should expect a tasting, not a large pour. Four wines can sound substantial, but each sample is there to compare styles and flavors rather than replace lunch. Bottled water is included, which is welcome when you are tasting several wines and oils close together.

Six olive oils, from natural to flavored

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting - Six olive oils, from natural to flavored

The olive oil tasting is one of the more unusual parts of the experience. Along with the natural extra virgin olive oil, you sample flavored oils made with basil, garlic, chili pepper, white truffle, and rosemary.

This range gives you a practical lesson in how oil changes a simple piece of bread. Basil can suggest a fresh, herbal direction. Garlic gives a stronger savory note. Chili pepper adds heat, while rosemary points toward the flavors often used with Tuscan beans, meat, and roasted vegetables. The white truffle oil is the most distinctive option, though truffle flavor can be powerful and not everyone enjoys it.

Bruschette and fresh bread are supplied for the tasting. Local cheeses and other small snacks are also part of the spread. Use the bread in small portions so you can compare the oils without filling up too early.

The supplied information also refers to balsamic vinegars in the tasting and in the farm’s own explanation of the experience. Since the detailed inclusion list focuses on six olive oils, four wines, bruschette, cheeses, snacks, and water, I would confirm the exact balsamic selection before booking if that is a deciding factor.

The same applies to the meal. The experience is described as including a three-course truffle-based meal, while the inclusion details describe bruschette, cheeses, and small snacks. That could mean a more substantial seasonal tasting menu, or it could reflect different booking descriptions. Ask what is being served on your date if you are expecting a full three-course lunch.

Outdoor tables, towers, and seasonal changes

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting - Outdoor tables, towers, and seasonal changes

The views are a real part of the experience, not just decoration. From the farm, you can look toward San Gimignano’s towers and the local Vernaccia vineyard. The combination helps you connect the bottle in your hand with the fields around you.

Outdoor seating is especially appealing in good weather. A wine tasting with open views feels different from one held at a counter inside a shop. You can take your time with the food, look back toward the town, and make the setting part of your visit.

Weather and season matter. In winter, the tasting may take place inside the historic farmhouse, which dates to the 15th century. You may lose some of the outdoor atmosphere, but you gain a setting with its own character. The farm’s indoor spaces are not a modern tasting bar, and that may suit you if you prefer an older rural building to a polished commercial venue.

Do not book this solely for a guaranteed close-up panorama of San Gimignano. The towers are visible, but from the tasting room the view can feel distant, especially if the weather is poor or the tasting is held indoors. The setting works best as a peaceful country view with the town in the background.

A private tasting, not a vineyard tour

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting - A private tasting, not a vineyard tour

The booking is private, so only your group participates. That is useful if you want a quieter table or prefer to ask questions without sharing the tasting with a large bus group.

At the same time, private does not automatically mean highly guided. The experience does not promise a detailed walk through the vineyards, a cellar visit, or a technical explanation of winemaking. You may receive clear information about what is being poured, but the depth of the presentation can depend on the person serving you.

That distinction matters. If you want to understand pruning, fermentation, aging, bottling, and organic farming in detail, this may feel too light. One account of the experience described the server as able to identify the wines being poured but not able to explain the full winemaking process. I would choose a dedicated winery tour if production details are your main goal.

If you mainly want to taste Tuscan wine and olive oil in a pleasant setting, the format makes more sense. You get several products in one sitting, without committing half a day to a large estate visit.

Is $66.09 a fair price?

At $66.09 per person, the value depends on what is actually served on your date. Four wines, six olive oils, cheeses, bruschette, bottled water, and a three-course truffle-based meal can make that price reasonable, particularly when you also value the private setting and the view.

The provider has also referred to an activity price of 30 euros in its response to a complaint. That is not the same as the listed price here, so prices may differ by booking channel, date, or package. Check the final amount and the precise food inclusions before paying.

The value is weaker if you receive only small pours and a few pieces of bread. A complaint about four half-slices of bread for two people shows why expectations matter. The farm’s response says the tasting includes fresh bread, mixed bruschette, Tuscan cheeses, four wines, six olive oils, and three balsamics. The descriptions are not perfectly consistent, so do not assume that every booking includes a large meal unless it is clearly stated at checkout.

You should also remember that farm products cost more than supermarket bottles. Organic cultivation involves more manual work and greater production risk, and the farm prices its wines and oils accordingly. Buying a bottle is optional, but you may find the retail prices high compared with other stops in Tuscany.

How to plan the visit

The meeting point is on Via Martiri di Citerna in San Gimignano. Since the activity lasts about 45 minutes, it fits neatly before or after a visit to the town’s towers, cathedral, and main streets.

In practice, allow extra time for walking from the center and finding the entrance. The advertised duration is approximate, and a tasting can finish within an hour. That makes it easy to combine with other sightseeing, but it also means you should not expect a long farm visit.

The booking is offered in English. Confirmation is received at booking, and the minimum age is 18. The minimum drinking age is also 18. Service animals are allowed, and the location is near public transportation, though private transportation and hotel pickup are not included.

The cancellation rule is simple: cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Changes or cancellations inside that window are not accepted for a refund.

Who will enjoy this experience most?

I would recommend it to couples, small groups, and food-minded visitors who want several Tuscan specialties in one stop. It is also a good fit if you are already visiting San Gimignano and want a short countryside break without booking a full-day wine excursion.

The private format suits people who value their own table. The views and farm setting also make it a pleasant choice for a relaxed afternoon rather than a technical wine lesson.

I would be more cautious if you are driving a large vehicle, have difficulty with steep or uneven access, or want a polished tasting room in the center of town. I would also look elsewhere if your priority is a guided vineyard walk, cellar tour, or detailed explanation of organic winemaking.

Should you book the Podere la Marronaia tasting?

Private wine, Extra Virgin Olive Oils & Cheese Tasting - Should you book the Podere la Marronaia tasting?

Book it if you want a short, private tasting near San Gimignano with local wine, olive oil, cheese, and countryside views. The organic farm setting, the variety of flavored oils, and the Vernaccia tasting give it a clear local identity.

Before booking, confirm two points: how much food is included, and whether your visit will be outdoors or inside. If you accept that this is a seated tasting rather than a full winery tour, the experience can be a convenient and tasty addition to a San Gimignano day.

FAQ

How far is the tasting from San Gimignano’s center?

The tasting venue is about 800 meters from the town center and is described as within walking distance.

How long does the tasting last?

The experience lasts approximately 45 minutes.

Which wines are included?

The tasting includes Vernaccia di San Gimignano DOCG bio, Chianti Colli Senesi DOCG organic or rosato IGT Toscano, Sangiovese IGT Rosso Toscano bio, and Vinsanto served with cantucci.

How many olive oils can I taste?

The tasting includes six oils: one natural extra virgin olive oil and five flavored oils made with basil, garlic, chili pepper, white truffle, and rosemary.

Is transportation included?

No. Hotel pickup, hotel drop-off, and private transportation are not included. You meet at Via Martiri di Citerna in San Gimignano, and the activity ends at the meeting point.

Can I cancel for a full refund?

Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours in advance are not accepted for a refund.

Scroll to Top

Find a cheese day

Pick a glass, a vat, a boat or a pot of fondue.